English (pdf)
Article in xml format
Article references
Automatic translation
Send this article by e-mail
Cited by SciELO 
Similars in
SciELO 
Permalink
Introduction
A cosmetic product, as defined by the 1223/2009 European Cosmetic Regulation, is any substance or mixture intended to be placed in contact with the external parts of the human body (epidermis, hair system, nails, lips and external genital organs) or with the teeth and the mucous membranes of the oral cavity, with an exclusive or main view to clean them, perfume them, change their appearance, protect them, keep them in good condition or correct body odors. Hair dyes or hair coloring products present one of the cosmetics products most used by the Moroccan population. Their use, both by men and women, continues to grow following fashion trends. Heavy metals are identified as one of the important contaminants in cosmetics products. Lead (as acetate) is used as a color additive in hair dyes (1, 2).
Some studies have demonstrated that the skin exposure to low levels of lead in hair dyes and tattoos may cause many health effects such as behavioral abnormalities, learning impairment, decreased hearing and impaired cognitive function. Cadmium is used in cosmetic products for its color property and it is added as impurities during the manufacturing process. Many studies described cadmium as carcinogenic and as a substance that may cause kidney damage for patients chronically exposed to it.
Other studies showed a relation between the exposure to cadmium and bone damage, with apparition of some symptoms such as low grade of bone mineralization, high rate of fractures and increased rate of osteoporosis (3, 4).
The toxicology and risk assessment of hair dyes have been subjects of many studies. These products are identified as the origin of various types of health problems, notably contact allergy, carcinogenicity, genetic and reproductive toxicity (5-7).
The present study aims to determine the concentration of lead and cadmium in different brands of hair dyes samples collected from the Moroccan market.
Among many methods described in the literature for trace determination, we chose differential pulse polarography (DPP), which is a very sensitive electro-chemical method for the determination of heavy metals in aqueous media (8).
Materials and methods
Instrumentation
All experiments were performed using a 797 VA Computrace (Metrohm, Germany) for polarographic trace analysis.
The differential pulse polarography technique (DPP) was used for the quantitative determination. The cell was equipped with three electrodes: the working electrode was a dropping mercury electrode (DME), platinum was used as counter electrode and Ag/AgCl/ (3 M KCl) as reference electrode. Nitrogen was used as an inert gas to operate the mercury electrode and to purge the analyte solutions.
The electrode drop time was 0.4 s. The polarograms were obtained by scanning the potential from -0.2 V to -0.7 V, with a pulse amplitude of 50 mV. The mineralization was performed using the Multiwave PRO microwave system (Anton Paar).
Reagents and solutions
Pure mercury (99.9 %), hydrogen peroxide (30 %), potassium chloride, trace metal free nitric acid (65 %, suprapure), lead nitrate and cadmium chloride were of analytical grade.
A standard solution of 1000 mg.L-1 of lead (Pb) was prepared using nitrate salts (Pb(NO3)2, and the standard solution of 1000 mg.L-1 of cadmium (Cd) was prepared using cadmium chloride (CdCl2). All solutions were prepared in double distilled water.
Sample mineralization and electrochemical analysis
Synthetic hair dyes and natural hair dyes samples were bought from Moroccan markets. Sixteen hair dyes were chosen. The brands, colors and their origin are listed in Table 1.
Table 1 List of tested brands, colors, and their country of origin
| Brand | Color | Country of origin |
|---|---|---|
| Brand-1-a (SHD) | Very light blonde | French |
| Brand-1-b (SHD) | Light ash blonde | French |
| Brand-1-c (SHD) | Brown | French |
| Brand-1-d (SHD) | Dark ash blonde | French |
| Brand-2-a (SHD) | Light brown | USA |
| Brand-2-b (SHD) | Dark blonde | USA |
| Brand-3-a (SHD) | Medium intense violet brown | Italy |
| Brand-3-b (SHD) | Light warm blonde | Italy |
| Brand-3-c (SHD) | Very light blonde | Italy |
| Brand-4-a (NHD) | Brown | Emirates (UAE) |
| Brand-4-b (NHD) | Maroon | Emirates (UAE) |
| Brand-4-c (NHD) | Dark brown | Emirates (UAE) |
| Brand-5-a (SHD) | Medium brown | Germany |
| Brand-5-b (SHD) | Light brown | Germany |
| Brand-5-c (SHD) | Medium natural brown | USA |
| Brand 6 (SHD) | Dark brown | French |
SHD: Synthetic Hair dye; NHD: Natural Hair dye.
Mineralization
A sample of 200 mg was placed in Teflon vessels and reacted with 4 mL of HNO3 for 4 hours in room temperature. After adding 1 mL of hydrogen peroxide, the sample solutions were putted into the microwave oven at 230 °C for 15 min. A blank solution was treated with the same protocol. The extracts were transferred to a polypropylene tube closed with a sealed cap.
Electrochemical analysis
Twenty milliliters of distilled water, 1 mL of supporting electrolyte and a sample of 100 µl were introduced into a polarographic cell. The supporting electrolyte was 1 M of KCL for both heavy metals. In the process of measurement, the solution was bubbled with pure nitrogen (99.999 %) for 180 s and after each analysis. The standard addition technique was used for the determination of heavy metals by three times additions of 100 µL of the standard solution in each addition.
Method validation
The method was validated according to ICH guidelines (9). The lead and cadmium curves calibrations were prepared each day during three days using the standard addition method. A known quantity of lead and cadmium standard solutions were added to give final concentrations in the range from 10 to 60 ppm for lead and in the range from 40 to 640 ppm for cadmium. The validation was carried out by studying the following parameters: linearity, accuracy, limit of detection (LOD), limit of quantitation (LOQ) and precision. The precision of the method was express as repeatability. LOQ and LOD were determined according to ICH recommendations: LOD = 3 (σ/S) and LOQ = 10 (σ/S), where σ is the standard deviation and S is the slope of the linear dynamic range.
Results
Method validation
The method has shown good linearity for both metals, with correlation coefficient values (r) of 0.992 and 0.999 for Cd and Pb, respectively. A good linear relationship was obtained; concentration was in the range from LOQ-0.6 mg L-1 to LOQ-0.64 mg L-1 for Pb and Cd, respectively. Due to the unavailability of an analyte free matrix, the accuracy was determined using a standard addition analysis technique. The analysis was conducted on the finished product spiked with a known amount of each metal. The results of the analytical validation method are given in Table 2.
Determination of lead and cadmium in hair dyes
Sixteen hair dyes were selected for the separate analysis of Pb and Cd using differential pulse polarography. The data presented in Table 3 show a summary of the descriptive statistical analysis of heavy metals in hair dyes.
Lead content in hair dyes
The overall median concentration (n = 16) of Pb analyzed was 1196.17 ppm [Q1= 960.69; Q3= 1490.19]. The highest concentration of Pb was obtained in brand-4-c (3617.02 ppm) and a non-detectable concentration was obtained in both hair dyes of brand 2 and brand-5-c. In the sixteen samples of brands of hair dyes, thirteen samples with extremely high lead level ranged from 448.43 to 3617.02 ppm. The Pb concentration in brown dyes of brands-1-3-4-5 was higher than that of other brown shades of the rest of brands and the Pb level in blonde dyes of brands-1-3 was considerately higher than that of other blonde shades. The brand-2 was the only brand where Pb has not been detected.
Table 3 Descriptive statistical summary of heavy metal concentration (mean ± SD) for six different brands in ppm and their price.
| Brand | Color | Pb (ppm) | Cd (ppm) | Price (€) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brand-1-a | Very light blonde | 1324,20 ± 0.001 | 54.79 ± 0.0001 | 11.50 |
| Brand-1-b | Light ash blonde | 1042.65 ± 0.001 | 56.87 ± 0.0001 | 11.50 |
| Brand-1-c | Brown | 1106.19 ± 0.001 | 53.09 ± 0.0001 | 11.50 |
| Brand-1-d | Dark ash blonde | 960.69 ± 0.001 | 52.40 ± 0.0001 | 11.50 |
| Brand-2-a | Light brown | < LOD | 113.20 ± 0.0001 | 8. 30 |
| Brand-2-b | Dark blonde | < LOD | 105.26 ± 0.0001 | 10. 65 |
| Brand-3-a | Medium intense violet brown | 1490.19 ± 0.001 | < LOD | 12.16 |
| Brand-3-b | Light warm blonde | 448.43 ± 0.001 | 53.81 ± 0.0001 | 12.16 |
| Brand-3-c | Very light blonde | 1574.07 ± 0.001 | 55.55 ± 0.0001 | 12.16 |
| Brand-4-a | Brown | 676.32 ± 0.001 | < LOD | 2 |
| Brand-4-b | Maroon | 1743.55 ± 0.001 | < LOD | 2 |
| Brand-4-c | Dark brown | 3617.02 ± 0.001 | 459.57 ± 0.0001 | 2 |
| Brand-5-a | Medium brown | 1196.17 ± 0.001 | 57.41 ± 0.0001 | 6. 79 |
| Brand-5-b | Light brown | 1414.63± 0.001 | < LOD | 7.95 |
| Brand-5-c | Medium brown naturel | < LOD | < LOD | 9.24 |
| Brand 6 | Brown | 585.93 ± 0.001 | 46.87 ± 0.0001 | 6.89 |
Cadmium content in hair dyes
The overall (n = 16) average concentration of Cd analyzed was 55.55 ppm [Q1= 53.54; Q3= 81.33], with the highest concentration in brand-4-c (459.57 ppm), and a non-detectable concentration in brand-3-a, brand-4-a, brand-4-b, brand-5-b and brand-5-c.
Cd concentrations in all samples of brand-1 were very similar, and the same goes for brand-2 and brand-3, except brand-3-a. The Cd concentration of dark brown dye of a natural hair dye (brand-4-c) was the highest concentration.
In the total, Pb and Cd have not been detected in medium brown natural shade from brand-5-c. On the other side, when comparing the results, the concentration of heavy metals is not related to brands in our study.
In conclusion, ten products have rates outside the acceptance limit for Pb and nine for Cd. The correlation test (Pearson) between concentration of heavy metals in hair dyes and the price was carried out. The two parameters were negatively correlated: r = -0,399 for Pb and r = -0,354 for Cd; this outcome means that the concentration of heavy metals increases with the decrease in price.
Discussion
The heavy metals content in cosmetic products is not regulated by the Moroccan authorities, and the values for the impurities of these substances are not standardized. However, it is admitted that lead and cadmium impurities in cosmetic products are unavoidable, due to the ubiquitous nature of these elements. The Health department from Canada states that heavy metal impurity concentrations in cosmetic products are technically avoidable when they exceed the following limits: 10 ppm for lead and 3 ppm for cadmium (10).
The German federal government has defined a maximum level of heavy metals in toothpastes and other cosmetic products and the levels of lead and cadmium are considered technically avoidable above, respectively, 20 ppm and 5 ppm (11, 12). FDA has published a guidance that recommends a level of 10 ppm for lead as an impurity in cosmetics. The same organization has conducted two surveys to determine cadmium and other heavy metals in a wide variety of cosmetic products, but the acceptable level of lead and cadmium in hair dyes has not been set (13). On the other side, the United Kingdom reported that a concentration of 1% of lead is still admitted in hair dyes (14) .
The hair dyes are classified into four categories: oxidative (permanent) dyes, direct (temporary or semi-permanent) dyes, metal salts and natural dyes (15).
In the present study, thirteen samples of direct dyes and three natural dyes were selected from different manufacturer’s countries and analyzed thereafter. A very high level of lead was detected in tested hair dyes according to all the limits mentioned before, and only three shades have a lead concentration below the LOD. The highest concentration of lead was obtained in a natural dye (brand-4-c); that result is in accordance with the result of Ozbek et al., which found a significantly higher lead level in natural hair dyes than that of the synthetics.
A second study of Jallad et al. reported the same outcome (15, 16). Henna-based natural dyes are not subject to the regulation of cosmetic products in Morocco, which may explain this high contamination by lead. The manner in which Moroccan women use the henna may develop the risk of intoxication. They apply the product for a long duration to obtain a good coloration, but this theory needs more investigations.
Another study about the determination of lead in hair dyes carried out on the Baghdad market in Iraq reported a maximum lead level of 0.92 ppm; that is much lower than the maximum reported in our study (1574.07 ppm) (17). This outcome may be attributed to the different origins of samples from various producers. Cadmium was not detected in five samples of hair dyes, while a cadmium concentration of 46.87 to 459.57 ppm was detected in the other hair dyes, which are higher than the limit fixed by various regulations (10, 11). The highest level of cadmium was found in a natural dye (brand-4-c), which also has the highest concentration of lead.
The concentration of cadmium in our synthetic hair dyes samples was higher than those reported by a study carried out in Nigeria, and higher than cadmium concentrations of natural hair dyes in the Turkey market (15, 18). Cadmium was reported as one of the toxic heavy metals causing harmful effects in a wide range of organs, which has an elimination half-life of 10-30 years (19). Cadmium toxicity includes renal, bone, kidney, dermal and metabolic damage. The exposure to low levels has been associated with cancer and heart diseases (19, 20).
For both analyzed metals, our results allow us to conclude that there is no automatic link between the lead content and brand or shades. On the other hand, the correlation between the concentration of heavy metals and the price was negative for both metals. This result can be explained by the fact that the producers who fix a higher price invest more in the control of their products. This correlation may also be due to the difference in the technologies used by each producer. Of course, there are some exceptions to those conclusions.
Conclusion
In the current study, lead and cadmium were determined in various synthetic and natural hair dyes using differential pulse polarography. A high concentration of both metals was found on many hair dyes, but the highest concentration was detected in one sample of natural hair dyes.
The use of cosmetic products contaminated with such metals can cause serious problems to the human body. These results represent new data on heavy metals in a category of cosmetic products marketed in Morocco and highlight the need to regulate the sector in order to protect the consumers.
